You want your policy to do one job on the hardest day: pay. Price and features matter, but the company’s financial strength is what keeps that promise standing 10, 20, even 40 years from now. I’m a licensed life insurance agent, and I’ll break down what ratings actually mean, how they ripple into your premium, dividends or crediting, and conversions—and what to do if your carrier’s score changes after you buy.
Independent agencies grade an insurer’s claims-paying ability and overall balance-sheet health. You’ll see letter grades and sometimes a composite score:
These aren’t stock picks. They’re a forward-looking view of whether the carrier can meet obligations through recessions, rate swings, claim spikes, and market storms.
Key idea: ratings speak to durability, not whether a specific product is “best.” A well-priced policy at an A-rated company often beats a pricey policy at an A++ company.
Your rate class (Preferred Plus, Preferred, Standard, tables) moves the bill the most. Ratings don’t set your class; underwriting does. But strong insurers usually access cheaper capital and reinsurance terms, which can support competitive pricing across popular terms and face bands.
Takeaway: shop carrier fit for your health profile first, then use ratings as a tie-breaker.
For mutuals and mutual-like carriers, dividend potential depends on investment income, expenses, and mortality experience. Strong balance sheets often correlate with steadier dividends over time. A notch down doesn’t kill dividends; it may tighten scales.
What to look at: current dividend scale history and guaranteed side. Pretty projections mean little if guarantees are thin.
Crediting rates and caps float with portfolio yields and hedging costs. Deep, well-managed portfolios tend to weather low-rate periods better, which can support less volatile caps and spreads.
Ask for: both guaranteed and current pages, plus a modest scenario that still works.
Guaranteed universal life leans on strict funding schedules and the insurer’s ability to price long promises. Stronger companies tend to maintain clear premium schedules through cycles. Late or short payments can still erode guarantees, regardless of rating—so autopay and reminders matter.
A carrier’s long-term stability supports the availability of permanent products you may convert into later. Richer conversion menus are easier to trust when the company has the balance sheet to sustain them.
Think of ratings as the foundation, not the floor plan.
For most families, carriers in the A-range and above (AM Best A− to A++ or comparable) offer strong claims-paying ability. If two quotes are close:
If a smaller carrier offers a much better fit for your health or a rider you actually need, an A− with a clean track record can still be a smart pick.
First, your contract is still your contract. The insurer can’t change guaranteed provisions on a whim.
A downgrade can trigger:
What you can do:
Switching solely for a letter change can backfire by restarting contestability and the suicide clock, and by exposing you to new underwriting. Move only if the math and fit improve.
You don’t need to be an actuary. When in doubt, ask your agent for a one-page carrier brief that translates these into plain English.
Fifteen minutes now beats hours of catch-up later.
“AAA or nothing.”
An A or A+ carrier with a strong track record can be a great choice, especially if it offers better underwriting for your health story.
“Higher rating always means lower premium.”
Not necessarily. Pricing also reflects reinsurance terms, capital costs, product design, and expense load.
“If a rating slips, I should switch.”
A downgrade is a signal to review, not a mandate to jump. Replacements carry new clocks and new underwriting.
“My group policy’s carrier rating protects me forever.”
Group coverage can change with employment. Own a personal policy that follows you.
Close tie, rating breaks it
Two carriers quoted the same $1M/30-year term within a dollar. One had a slightly higher Comdex and broader conversion. Client chose that one—stronger foundation and a future option.
Downgrade panic averted
Client saw a headline, called in a rush. We ran an in-force on their GUL, verified funding, and set autopay reminders. No switch needed; guarantee stayed intact.
Whole life expectations reset
Dividend scale eased across the industry. We walked through guaranteed vs current values and trimmed paid-up additions to keep the plan comfortable. Strength rating stayed high; the plan stayed on course.
Term conversion action
Carrier stayed strong, but a product on the conversion menu was scheduled to close. We converted $75k early to lock the option and left the rest of the term in place.
“Please send $[amount] for [term length] with the same specs across 2–3 carriers. Include: the health class you used and the class you expect for me, no-exam and exam pricing, monthly-EFT and annual totals, the next face tier, term conversion deadline with a $50k example, and each carrier’s current AM Best/S&P/Moody’s/Fitch plus Comdex.”
You’ll get apples-to-apples numbers and the strength picture in one view.
Ratings don’t buy groceries, but they do tell you how likely a company is to pay your family on time decades from now. Use them as a foundation: pick carriers that fit your health and budget, then let financial strength break ties and guide long-term choices like conversions and permanent designs. If ratings shift after you buy, review calmly, pull fresh illustrations, and keep your guarantees funded.
Need help? Send your age, state, coverage goal, term vs permanent preference, and a monthly range that feels right. I’ll share side-by-sides from strong carriers, translate the ratings into plain talk, and set you up with a policy that’s built to last.
Receive the latest life insurance updates in your inbox.
